Separate download rights from the "Can Comment" permission

Sharing a video with “Can Comment” access also lets that person download the MP4. I have not found a way to grant comment access without download access. If that setting exists and I missed it, I would appreciate the correction.

The use case is client and stakeholder review of unfinished work. Reviewers need to leave timestamped comments on a draft. They do not need a file.

Two problems follow. The first is intellectual property exposure. Proprietary, unreleased content leaves the workspace the moment we invite feedback, and the download is invisible to the owner.

The second is version drift, which the version selector makes worse. A reviewer can download any generated version, including one we have already replaced, and that file has no expiry and no indication that it is stale. We have no way to know an outdated cut is circulating or sitting in a folder waiting to be used. 😲

The request is a download toggle on the Can Comment permission level, defaulting to off, with a workspace setting under Roles and Permissions so admins can enforce it rather than relying on whoever creates the share. Advanced settings on public links already separate duplication from viewing, so the precedent for this kind of toggle is there.

❓One question for the community: If you’ve found a workaround that doesn’t involve another software, can you share?

❓One question for developers: If this isn’t already on the roadmap, can we add it?